LOG-NET Carbon Calculator - Educational Notes
Primary factors impacting carbon dioxide emissions in international trade
The selection of transport modes plays a critical role in determining emission levels for international shipments. Different combinations of transport modes for a trip from the same origin to the same destination can yield substantially different emission levels.
Inland Mode Selection
While many countries are constrained in their ability to provide efficient inland transportation to and from port areas via rail, it is a much more carbon-efficient mode of transport and usually is much more cost-effective. Countries developing their inland rail networks, particularly their intermodal stacked container rail services, will greatly reduce their levels of emissions. Modern intermodal transfer facilities which interchange ocean containers to and from rail movement enable rail alternatives that can have equal transit times with much lower fuel consumption. Intermodal rail has the added benefit of reducing road congestion.
Intercontinental Mode Selection
For long-distance voyages, the faster transit times of air shipments come at a price of greatly increased emission levels. Air shipments can generate emissions approximately five times higher than those generated by an ocean voyage for the same set of cargo. Aircraft emissions also have a greater effect due to their occurrence at high altitudes, where they can trigger a set of chemical reactions that magnifies their impact. The IPCC has estimated that the climate impact of air transport is two to four times greater than the effect generated by the carbon dioxide emissions alone.
Routing and Route Selection
For all modes of travel, emission levels are strongly dependent on the distance traveled by the transport vehicle. LOG-NET's Carbon Calculator models these distances in various ways, depending on the mode of transport.
Ocean voyage distances are built around standard international trade lanes, using great-circle distances to measure long open-water segments of the voyage, and routing around land masses and through canals, where available. LOG-NET's routing database includes information about specific port locations and approaches for many of the world's largest container ports, and these port-specific routing features are part of the distance calculation between various pairs of ports.
Distances traveled by motor transport over the public highway infrastructure is calculated by actual on-the-road distance measurements using the shortest available route between the two locations. Motor routing data is available for many countries worldwide, including most major importers and exporters of international container shipments. For countries where road routing information is not available, the straight-line distance between the locations is used as a starting point, and modified by a constant factor to approximate the extra distance traveled over the roadways.
The exact distance traveled by rail shipments depends on the details of the rail network used by the particular carrier, and this data is generally not available for specific arbitrary pairs of locations. Instead, LOG-NET has calculated the average factors by which rail distances typically exceed straight-line distances, based on available rail data in the United States, Europe, and Asia. These factors are used to estimate the rail distance between any pair of locations, based on the straight-line distance between the locations.
LOG-NET models air transport distances using a straight-line, great-circle distance between the origin and destination. Actual routes flown by commercial transport aircraft may differ from the straight-line distance based on current weather conditions and seasonal climate patterns, but distances are generally quite close to the straight-line distance.
Vessel classes can be categorized in terms of their evolution over the past 10 to 15 years. Older vessels capable of carrying 6,000 TEU are being replaced by vessels able to carry 8,000 or 10,000 TEU. Most of these ships have engines of 40,000 to 60,000 horsepower. As a result the work that the engine performs has been able to move more and more containers per unit of fuel burned, and subsequently, carbon dioxide emitted. Many very large vessels cannot transit the Panama Canal. These vessels exceed the width of the canal. Work is active today to expand the capacity of the canal.
Arrivals and Departures
Arrivals and departures can be one of the most carbon-costly portions of a journey in any mode of transport. Vessels maneuver in and out of port, flights burn more fuel taking off and landing, and rail engines burn more fuel per unit as they maneuver to efficient operating speeds on their primary routes. LOG-NET's Carbon Calculator models these effects, and their impact on emission levels. The effect of arrivals and departures is particularly evident for air transport, where fuel consumption during takeoff and climb to cruising altitude can be up to ten times greater than that consumed during level flight. As a result, short-distance air journeys result in a significantly higher level of emissions per unit distance, as compared to longer journeys.
Type of Fuel
LOG-NET's Carbon Calculator uses a model that considers that different types of fuel used by the engines in various forms of transport vehicles. Jet fuel, light diesel and heavy diesel are each composed of hydrocarbon molecules with different numbers of carbon atoms. Each fuel will thus generate a different volume of CO2 for each ton of fuel burned.
For ocean transport, one important factor is the amount of time spent in port. During this period, the vessel must use smaller, less-efficient auxiliary power generators, or shore power, in order to continue to operate. Larger vessels spend more time in port loading and unloading than smaller vessels, and port operations can also generate substantial CO2. LOG-NET's Carbon Calculator models the impact of emissions generated during a vessel's time in port, including the additional time required to service larger vessels.